Well, are you?

A phrase coined by FBSO's MaxieMan while attempting to use some creative wordplay.

While Speaking to Sho one night, MaxieMan became aware of something incredulous that warrented a clever response. He immediately thought of using an adjective to enhance the phrase "Are You Jokin Me?" and achieved startling results.

By the time he realized what he had said, Sho and the other members in the channel had dropped the conversation and were laughing so hard their sides were hurting. This was the birth of a new term for use in ironic or unbelievable situations.